Unofficial, independent hub · not affiliated with any studio, publisher or creator · how we work

Fan theoryOne PieceUpdated Nov 16, 2026 · 6 sources

One Piece Fans Debate Imu's Power, Blackbeard, and Gunko

A marble throne in a moonlit indoor garden seen through an arched window, with dark shadows creeping across the floor.
Illustration made for this site, not from the show.

Recent discussions on the r/OnePiece subreddit focus heavily on Imu's true form and abilities, alongside ongoing debates about whether Blackbeard will defeat Imu and whether the Gunko flashback slows down the main story involving Luffy, Loki, and Harald.

Imu's Real Form, Devil Fruit Speculation, and the Blackbeard Theory

Following the reveal of Imu's real form roughly 20 chapters ago, fans on r/OnePiece are questioning the popular fan theory that Blackbeard will kill Imu. One user argued that having Blackbeard eliminate Imu immediately upon returning to Mariejois would waste the mystery, buildup, and anticipation surrounding the character.

Readers are also speculating about the exact nature of Imu's abilities. One theory shared on the subreddit suggests Imu might possess a failed Zoan-type Devil Fruit that ended up taking over its host's body. Meanwhile, another fan raised the question of whether Garling would die if Imu removed his mark, though no consensus or confirmed answer exists yet.

Power Scaling Debates: Luffy, Loki, Rocks, and Young Kaido

Imu's combat strength has sparked heated debate among readers. One post criticized fans for misinterpreting chapters regarding Rocks, pointing out that Luffy and Loki did not defeat any version of Imu and were overwhelmed the entire time. The same user criticized Imu's transformations as feeling unearned, calling current Imu power scaling irrelevant.

On the other hand, some fans are using past encounters with Imu to defend Kaido's reputation. A post on r/OnePiece reminded readers that when Kaido was a 21-year-old pirate with zero experience using his new Devil Fruit, he charged straight at Imu less than 10 minutes after eating it just to test his powers.

Divided Reactions to the Gunko Flashback

Away from the debates over Imu, community members are also questioning the pacing of the current arc. A discussion thread on r/OnePiece asked whether the entire Gunko flashback was unnecessary, arguing that it distracts from the main plot centered on Luffy, Loki, and Harald.

Two sides of the debate

Imu's Role and Encounters Are Central to the Story

  • Imu's real form was only revealed around 20 chapters ago, so having Blackbeard kill Imu right after returning to Mariejois would waste years of buildup and mystery.
  • Charging at Imu to test a brand-new Devil Fruit at age 21 is cited by fans as proof that Kaido deserves respect against community slander.
  • Imu's abilities continue to drive fan theories, including speculation about a failed Zoan taking over its host and whether Garling's life depends on Imu's mark.

Criticism of Imu's Transformations and Arc Pacing

  • Some readers argue that Imu has unearned transformations and transforms just for fun, making Imu power scaling irrelevant despite overwhelming Luffy and Loki.
  • Popular fan theories still suggest Blackbeard could kill Imu upon returning to Mariejois, prompting pushback from other readers.
  • Critics of the recent pacing argue that the Gunko flashback was unnecessary because it pulls focus away from the main plot about Luffy, Loki, and Harald.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: Where do you stand on the major One Piece community debates right now?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Do you think Blackbeard will eventually overthrow Imu, or would that cut Imu's buildup short after we only recently saw their real form?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from NextCour

Fan theoryKagurabachiKagurabachi Ch. 139 Theories: Prototype Blade, Giyu & Chiaki's FateFollowing the latest chapter of Kagurabachi, readers on r/Kagurabachi are analyzing the deep dive into the Seitei War. Discussions center on Giyu's one-armed arrival at Yagira, the mechanics of the prototype Enchanted Blade, and major disagreements over whether Shurin captures Chiaki.UnverifiedKagurabachiKagurabachi Fans Debate John Werry's English Translation After Chapter 139Following the latest English release of Kagurabachi, readers on Reddit noticed that John Werry was credited as the translator. While it is not known yet whether Werry is the permanent translator going forward, his arrival has sparked intense debate across the r/Kagurabachi community over dialogue flow, localized Enchanted Blade names, and his past work on Jujutsu Kaisen.Fan theoryKagurabachiSumika vs. Flame Bone: Kagurabachi Power DebateRecent community discussions on the r/Kagurabachi forum have sparked intense debates over the manga's power hierarchy. Readers are currently weighing the combat utility of Sumika against Flame Bone, comparing the new generation of Enchanted Blade bearers to Setei War veterans, and analyzing how Hokazono illustrates high-speed clashes.UnverifiedOne PieceOne Piece Added to Disney Plus Without Subtitles, Sparking Fan ConfusionCommunity members on Reddit recently noticed that One Piece appears to be available on Disney Plus. However, viewers attempting to rewatch the series report that only English audio is currently selectable, with no subtitled version offered on the platform.